Published On: November 16, 20265 min read

By C.J. Rauch

Great teachers promote interactions with students that are based on mutual respect; we know this is an important element of creating a supportive environment where learning can take place (Coe et al., 2020). My colleague Rachel Conlon-Bose has recently written about findings from about teachers’ respect towards students, based on feedback tools within the Great Teaching Toolkit. The blog is worth a read, but in short, it argues that there are generally positive views of teacher respect in classrooms, but that teachers sometimes struggle to express or communicate that respect to all students.

So what does it mean in to show respect to our students in practice? And how can teachers ensure that this respect is clearly communicated to students?

Respect in a classroom

The Great Teaching Toolkit: Evidence review summarises the importance of teachers’ respect and sensitivity towards students (Coe et al., 2020). A classroom where students feel respected is important for classroom management and maximising opportunity to learn. It also encourages mutual, reciprocal feelings of respect from students; this is crucial if we expect students to engage in challenging learning, which is marked with feelings of vulnerability.

In addition to building trust towards teachers’ curricular and pedagogical expertise, I think many of us would agree that environments built on mutual respect are simply more pleasant to be in! But what does it actually look like in practice?

The difficulty is that respectful practices are not universal, objective acts. They are subject to culture, context, values, and norms. I remember as a young student being told that we don’t wear hats in school because to do so “would be disrespectful to your teachers”. This seemed absolutely absurd to six-year-old me—how are these two things connected?!

Fast-forward a couple of decades to when I was a teacher. Our school had set a goal of essentially trying to increase students’ sense of belonging (although this was well before the term was popular). Some of the school’s leadership “strongly encouraged” us to begin every lesson by going around the room and greeting each student, individually, by name—even at the cost of instructional time. The idea was this would make them feel welcome, valued, and respected. I couldn’t help by finding myself asking the same question… How was doing this connected to feeling respected?

This became especially true when deploying this strategy felt more like checkbox activity than a meaningful one. And it was especially apparent to the students this was a rather contrived interaction.

Lethal mutations in a technique

This “strongly encouraged” practice was certainly well-intentioned; and it even may have had links to decent research. Some small-scale studies have looked on the effects of greeting students and found positive effects on classroom behaviour and academic achievement (e.g., Allday & Kakurar, 2013; Cook et al., 2018). But the specific practice was a classic example of a lethal mutation, the modification of ideas and techniques that they are so different from the original that they are no longer effective.

For example, in some of the existing research about greeting students, the greeting and address by name is probably not the “active ingredient” or reason why it worked. For example, Allday & Pakurar (2013) coupled the greeting with a reminder of the specific actions on how to begin the lesson tasks. In the study by Cook et al. (2018), the greeting was by a meaningful, positive connection. Simply using a student’s name misses both of these points present in the original research.

Lethal mutations can creep into any teaching strategy or technique. Building a deep understanding and varied practice can help us reduce the risk of something becoming a checkbox exercise—especially for potentially abstract or subjective concepts like “demonstration respect”.

Genuine respect

So what can teachers practically do to communicate their respect towards all students? To build off Aristotle, I do believe that genuine respect is formed by doing genuinely respectful actions. This is also to say that actions that seem to be superficial—greeting someone by name, removing a hat, and so on—will probably not lead to genuine feelings of respect.

The Great Teaching Toolkit: Evidence review tells us that having a deep and holistic understanding of who are students are is essential (Coe et al., 2020). And yes, this does mean knowing and using their preferred name in a genuine conversational way! But it also means understanding their passions, interests, background, fears, values, influences, and who they are outside as well as inside our classroom.

Greeting students by name is a fine first step in communicating respect and trying to build a sense of belonging, by it needs to be followed by genuine interest, care, empathy, and respect! Of course, there is no list of questions or conversations topics to do this. It takes time and deliberate effort, as all good professional learning does.

In the next few blogs, we’ll continue exploring the concepts of respect and belonging in a classroom. My colleague Rachel Conlon-Bose will be taking a look at more data from the Great Teaching Toolkit to show more about what student’s report about their classroom environments.

References

Allday, R. A., & Pakurar, K. (2007). Effects of teacher greetings on student on‐task behavior. Journal of applied behavior analysis, 40(2), 317-320. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.2007.86-06

Coe, R., Rauch, C.J., Kime, S. & Singleton, D. (2020). Great Teaching Toolkit: Evidence review. Evidence Based Education. https://evidencebased.education/reports/

Cook, C. R., Fiat, A., Larson, M., Daikos, C., Slemrod, T., Holland, E. A., Thayer, A. J. & Renshaw, T. (2018). Positive greetings at the door: Evaluation of a low-cost, high-yield proactive classroom management strategy. Journal of Positive Behavior Interventions, 20(3), 149-159. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098300717753831

Your next steps in becoming a Great Teaching school

See the Great Teaching Toolkit platform and what it can do for you!

Request a quote for your school, college or Group!

Still thinking about how the Toolkit can be implemented in your context?